"We had a server error" on Reddit almost never means Reddit's servers are actually down. It's Reddit's way of telling you your account has been shadowbanned, suspended, or your IP has been flagged without explicitly saying so. If other users can browse Reddit fine but you keep seeing this message, the problem is your account.
Below: how to diagnose the real cause (shadowban vs suspension vs IP ban vs actual outage), how to fix each one, and how to never see this message again.
What This Error Actually Means
Reddit shows "We had a server error" as a catch-all message. It covers everything from genuine server outages to stealth bans. Reddit intentionally keeps the message vague so banned users don't immediately know they've been banned. This is by design.
When you see this error, here's what's actually happening in order of likelihood:
Step 1: Diagnose the Problem
Before trying any fix, figure out which of the three causes you're dealing with:
Test 1: Check if Reddit is actually down. Ask a friend to try Reddit, or check DownDetector. If everyone can use Reddit except you, it's not a server issue. It's your account or IP.
Test 2: Check for shadowban. Open a private/incognito window. Go to reddit.com/u/YOUR_USERNAME. If the page shows "page not found" or your profile doesn't load, you're shadowbanned. You can also use cable.ayra.ch/reddit as a checker.
Test 3: Check for IP ban. Try logging into a completely different Reddit account from the same network. If that account also gets the error, your IP is flagged. Try switching to mobile data (different IP) to confirm.
Test 4: Check for suspension. Try to log in on reddit.com. If Reddit explicitly shows a suspension message or redirects you to an appeal page, your account has been formally suspended (different from shadowban).
Step 2: Fix Based on Cause
If you're shadowbanned
Go to reddit.com/appeal and submit an appeal. Be honest, brief, and polite. If your account was caught in an automated anti-spam sweep (common for marketing accounts), appeals often succeed within 24-72 hours. If the appeal fails, you'll need a new account. This time, warm it up properly before any promotion.
If your IP is banned
Your IP has been flagged, usually from VPNs with shared IPs or proxies previously used by spammers. Solutions: switch to mobile data, use a residential proxy with a clean IP, or contact your ISP for a new IP (restarting your router sometimes works with dynamic IPs). See our Reddit proxy guide for recommended providers.
If your account is suspended
Reddit suspensions are formal. You'll usually see a clear message. Appeal at reddit.com/appeal. If the suspension was for spam or manipulation, explain what you'll do differently. If it was a mistake, say so calmly. Suspensions are harder to reverse than shadowbans but not impossible.
If Reddit is actually down
Wait. Check DownDetector or Reddit's Twitter/X for status updates. Genuine outages are usually fixed within minutes to a few hours. There's nothing to fix on your end.
Why This Happens to Reddit Marketers
If you're doing Reddit marketing, you're significantly more likely to see this error than a casual user. The most common triggers:
Using automation tools that post on your behalf. Any tool that logs into your Reddit account and posts automatically is detectable. Reddit flags the behavior pattern, not just the tool. See why accounts get banned.
Posting too frequently without warmup. New accounts that immediately start posting promotional content get flagged. Reddit expects a gradual ramp-up. Follow a proper posting schedule.
Multiple accounts on the same IP. Managing several Reddit accounts from the same network without proper isolation triggers Reddit's coordinated behavior detection. See our multi-account setup guide.
Low CQS (Contributor Quality Score). Accounts with low CQS are more likely to get flagged by automated systems. Building CQS through genuine engagement is the best protection.
VPNs with shared/flagged IPs. Free VPNs and cheap proxies often use IPs that have been previously flagged by Reddit. Using them connects your account to a "dirty" IP.
How to Never See This Error Again
The error is a symptom. The cause is usually an unsafe Reddit marketing approach. Here's the prevention stack:
2-4 weeks of genuine browsing and commenting before any promotion. Full warming protocol here.
Get your CQS to High through quality comments. 9 methods to improve CQS.
Any tool that posts to Reddit from your account automatically is detectable. Use tools that find conversations and draft replies, but always post manually yourself.
Residential proxies, not datacenter VPNs. One IP per account. Best proxies for Reddit.
9 genuine comments for every 1 promotional one. This ratio keeps your account safe and your CQS healthy.
Reppit AI ($25/mo) is built around this safe approach: it finds high-intent conversations and generates smart reply drafts, but you always post manually from your own account. No automation touching your Reddit login. No risk of triggering "we had a server error" from the tool itself. The intelligence layer without the ban risk.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does "we had a server error" mean on Reddit?
In most cases, it means your account is shadowbanned, suspended, or your IP is flagged. Reddit uses this vague message instead of telling you directly. If others can use Reddit fine, it's your account, not Reddit's servers.
How do I check if I'm shadowbanned?
Open incognito/private browsing. Go to reddit.com/u/YOUR_USERNAME. If it shows "page not found," you're shadowbanned. Also try cable.ayra.ch/reddit.
Can I fix a Reddit shadowban?
Appeal at reddit.com/appeal. Automated shadowbans are often reversed within 24-72 hours. If the appeal fails, create a new account and warm it up properly.
AI finds prospects. AI drafts replies. You post manually. Account stays safe. $25/mo.
Start Safe Reddit Marketing